PaliRoman Vol.17

[182] Ekam samayam bhagava savatthiyam viharati pubbarame migaramatupasade mahata bhikkhusanghena saddhim . tena kho pana samayena bhagava tadahuposathe pannarase punnaya ^4- punnamaya rattiya bhikkhusanghaparivuto ajjhokase nisinno hoti. [183] Atha kho annataro bhikkhu utthayasana ekamsam uttarasangam karitva yena bhagava tenanjalimpanametva bhagavantam etadavoca puccheyyaham bhante bhagavantam kinci ^5- deva desam sace me bhagava okasam karoti panhassa veyyakaranayati . tenahi tvam bhikkhu sake asane nisiditva puccha yadakankhasiti . evam bhanteti kho so bhikkhu bhagavato patissutva sake asane nisiditva bhagavantam @Footnote: ¹ Po. vicikicchita aditthigata . ² Po. ya kho panima bhikkhave. @³ Po. evam kho. ⁴ Po. sampunnaya . ⁵ Po. kinci teneva. Etadavoca ime nu kho bhante pancupadanakkhandha . seyyathidam . Rupupadanakkhandho vedanupadanakkhandho sannupadanakkhandho sankharupadanakkhandho vinnanupadanakkhandhoti . ime kho bhikkhu pancupadanakkhandha . seyyathidam . rupupadanakkhandho .pe. Vinnanupadanakkhandhoti. [184] Sadhu bhanteti kho so bhikkhu bhagavato bhasitam abhinanditva anumoditva bhagavantam uttarim panham apucchi ^1- ime kho pana bhante pancupadanakkhandha kimmulakati . ime kho bhikkhu pancupadanakkhandha chandamulakati .pe. Tanneva ^2- nu kho bhante upadanam te ca ^3- pancupadanakkhandha. Udahu annatra pancahi ^4- upadanakkhandhehi ^4- upadananti . Na kho bhikkhu tanneva upadanam te ca pancupadanakkhandha napi ^5- annatra pancahi upadanakkhandhehi upadanam apica yo ^6- tattha chandarago tam ^7- tattha upadananti. [185] Sadhu bhanteti kho so bhikkhu .pe. uttarim panham apucchi siya pana bhante pancupadanakkhandhesu chandaragavemattatati . Siya bhikkhuti bhagava avoca idha bhikkhu ekaccassa ^8- evam hoti evamrupo siyam anagatamaddhanam evamvedano siyam anagatamaddhanam evamsanano ^9- siyam anagatamaddhanam evamsankharo siyam @Footnote: ¹ Po. pucchi . ² Po. tadanneva . ³ Si. Ma. cakaro na dissati. @⁴ Yu. pancupadanakkhandhehi . ⁵ Ma. Yu. napi. Po. pisaddo na dissati. @⁶ Po. kho. ⁷ Po. tanti na dissati . ⁸ Po. ekassa yatha evam. @⁹ Po. Yu. evamsanni. Anagatamaddhanam evamvinnano siyam anagatamaddhananti ^1- . evam kho bhikkhu siya pancupadanakkhandhesu chandaragavemattatati. [186] Sadhu bhanteti kho so bhikkhu .pe. uttarim panham apucchi kittavata nu kho bhante khandhanam khandhadhivacananti . yankinci bhikkhu ^2- rupam atitanagatapaccuppannam ajjhattam va bahiddha va olarikam va sukhumam va hinam va panitam va yam dure ^[3]- santike va . Ayam vuccati rupakkhandho ^4-. Ya kaci vedana. Ya kaci sanna. Ye keci sankhara . yankinci vinnanam atitanagatapaccuppannam ajjhattam va bahiddha va olarikam va sukhumam va hinam va panitam va yam dure santike va . Ayam vuccati vinnanakkhandho. Ettavata ^[5]- kho bhikkhu khandhanam khandhadhivacananti. [187] Sadhu bhanteti kho so bhikkhu .pe. apucchi ko nu kho bhante hetu ko paccayo rupakkhandhassa pannapanaya . Ko hetu ko paccayo vedanakkhandhassa pannapanaya . ko hetu ko paccayo sannakkhandhassa pannapanaya . ko hetu ko paccayo sankharakkhandhassa pannapanaya . ko hetu ko paccayo vinnanakkhandhassa pannapanayati . cattaro kho bhikkhu mahabhuta hetu cattaro mahabhuta paccayo ^6- rupakkhandhassa pannapanaya . Phasso hetu phasso paccayo vedanakkhandhassa pannapanaya . phasso hetu phasso paccayo sannakkhandhassa pannapanaya . phasso @Footnote: ¹ Yu. itisaddo na dissati . ² Yu. bhikkhave . ³ Po. vasaddo dissati. @⁴ Po. rupakkhandhoti . ⁵ Po. casaddo dissati . ⁶ Po. paccaya. Hetu phasso paccayo sankharakkhandhassa pannapanaya . namarupam hetu namarupam paccayo vinnanakkhandhassa pannapanayati. [188] Sadhu bhanteti kho so bhikkhu .pe. apucchi katham nu kho bhante sakkayaditthi hotiti . idha bhikkhu assutava puthujjano ariyanam adassavi ariyadhammassa akovido ariyadhamme avinito sappurisanam adassavi sappurisadhammassa akovido sappurisadhamme avinito rupam attato samanupassati rupavantam va attanam attani va rupam rupasmim va attanam . vedanam . sannam . sankhare . Vinnanam attato samanupassati vinnanavantam va attanam attani va vinnanam vinnanasmim va attanam . evam kho bhikkhu sakkayaditthi hotiti. [189] Sadhu bhanteti kho so bhikkhu .pe. apucchi katham pana bhante sakkayaditthi na hotiti . idha bhikkhu sutava ariyasavako ariyanam dassavi ariyadhammassa kovido ariyadhamme suvinito sappurisanam dassavi sappurisadhammassa ^1- kovido sappurisadhamme suvinito na rupam attato samanupassati na rupavantam va attanam na attani va rupam na rupasmim va attanam . na vedanam . na sannam . na sankhare . na vinnanam attato samanupassati na vinnanavantam va attanam na attani va vinnanam na vinnanasmim va attanam. Evam kho bhikkhu sakkayaditthi na hotiti. @Footnote: ¹ Po. sappurisadhammesu. [190] Sadhu bhanteti kho so bhikkhu .pe. ko nu kho bhante rupassa assado ko adinavo kim nissaranam . ko vedanaya . ko sannaya . ko sankharanam . ko vinnanassa assado ko adinavo kim nissarananti . yam kho bhikkhu rupam paticca uppajjati sukham somanassam ayam rupassa assado yam rupam aniccam dukkham viparinanadhammam ayam rupassa adinavo yo rupasmim chandaragavinayo chandaragappahanam idam rupassa nissaranam . Yam vedanam paticca . yam sannam paticca . yam ^1- sankhare paticca. Yam vinnanam paticca uppajjati sukham somanassam ayam vinnanassa assado yam vinnanam aniccam dukkham viparinamadhammam ayam vinnanassa adinavo yo vinnanasmim chandaragavinayo chandaragappahanam idam vinnanassa nissarananti. [191] Sadhu bhanteti kho so bhikkhu bhagavato bhasitam abhinanditva anumoditva bhagavantam uttarim panham apucchi katham nu kho bhante janato katham passato imasminca savinnanake kaye bahiddha ca sabbanimittesu ahankaramamankaramananusaya na hontiti . Yankinci bhikkhu rupam atitanagatapaccuppannam ajjhattam va bahiddha va olarikam va sukhumam va hinam va panitam va yam dure santike va sabbam rupam netam mama nesohamasmi na meso attati evametam yathabhutam sammappannaya passati . ya kaci vedana . @Footnote: ¹ Ma. Yu. ye. Ya kaci sanna . ye keci sankhara . yankinci vinnanam atitanagatapaccuppannam ajjhattam va bahiddha va olarikam va sukhumam va hinam va panitam va yam dure santike va sabbam vinnanam netam mama nesohamasmi na meso attati evametam yathabhutam sammappannaya passati . evam kho bhikkhu janato evam passato imasminca ^[1]- savinnanake kaye bahiddha ca sabbanimittesu ahankaramamankaramananusaya na hontiti. [192] Tena kho pana samayena annatarassa bhikkhuno evam cetaso parivitakko udapadi iti kira bho rupam anatta . vedana . Sanna . sankhara . vinnanam anatta anattakatani kammani kammattanam ^2- phusissantiti . atha kho bhagava tassa bhikkhuno cetasa ^3- cetoparivitakkamannaya bhikkhu amantesi thanam kho panetam bhikkhave vijjati yam idhekacco moghapuriso avijjagato ^4- tanhadhigatena cetasa satthu sasanam atidhavitabbam ^5- manneyya iti kira bho rupam anatta . vedana . sanna . sankhara . vinnanam anatta anattakatani kammani kammattanam phusissantiti ^6- . patipuccha vinita kho me tumhe bhikkhave tatra tatra tesu tesu ^7- dhammesu tam kim mannatha bhikkhave rupam niccam va aniccam vati . aniccam bhante. Vedana . sanna . sankhara . vinnanam niccam va aniccam @Footnote: ¹ Po. panasaddo dissati . ² Ma. u. 106. kamattanam. Ma. kathamattanam. Si. Yu. @katamattanam . ³ Po. cetaso . ⁴ Po. avijjatanhadhigatena. Ma. Yu. avidva @avijjagato tanhadhipateyyena . ⁵ Po. atividhatabbam. @⁶ Yu. itisaddo na dissati. ⁷ Po. Yu. tesuti na dissati. Vati . aniccam bhante . yam pananiccam dukkham va tam sukham vati. Dukkham bhante . yam pananiccam dukkham viparinamadhammam kallam nu tam samanupassitum etam mama esohamasmi eso me attati . no hetam bhante . tasma tiha .pe. evam passam .pe. naparam itthattayati pajanatiti. Dve khandha tanneva siyam adhivacanam ca hetuna ^1- sakkayena ^2- duve vutta assadavinnanakena ca ete dasavidha vutta hoti bhikkhu pucchayati ^3- ^4-. Khajjaniyavaggo tatiyo. Tassuddanam assado dve samudaya ^5- arahantehi apare dve siho ^6- khajjanipindolyam palileyyena punnamati. ------------- @Footnote: ¹ Po. dve dittha tanneva piyam adhivacana ca hetuna . ² Yu. satta yena. @³ Po. paccaya . ⁴ Si. ayam gatha na dissati . ⁵ Po. samudayo . ⁶ Yu. siha.

The Pali Tipitaka in Roman Character Volume 17 page 121-127. https://84000.org/tipitaka/read/roman_read.php?B=17&A=2464&modeTY=2 Compare with The Pali Tipitaka in Thai Character :- https://84000.org/tipitaka/read/pali_read.php?B=17&A=2464&modeTY=2 Compare with The Royal Version of Thai Tipitaka :- https://84000.org/tipitaka/read/byitem.php?book=17&item=182&items=11 Compare with The MCU Version of Thai Tipitaka :- https://84000.org/tipitaka/pitaka_item/m_siri.php?B=17&siri=82 Study Atthakatha :- https://84000.org/tipitaka/attha/attha.php?b=17&i=182 The Pali Atthakatha in Thai :- https://84000.org/tipitaka/atthapali/read_th.php?B=12&A=7412 The Pali Atthakatha in Roman :- https://84000.org/tipitaka/atthapali/read_rm.php?B=12&A=7412 Contents of The Tipitaka Volume 17 https://84000.org/tipitaka/read/?index_17 https://84000.org/tipitaka/english/?index_17