PaliRoman Vol.10

page65.

Mahanidanasuttam [57] Evamme sutam . ekam samayam bhagava kurusu viharati kammasadammam ^1- nama kurunam nigamo . athakho ayasma anando yena bhagava tenupasankami upasankamitva bhagavantam abhivadetva ekamantam nisidi . ekamantam nisinno kho ayasma anando bhagavantam etadavoca acchariyam bhante abbhutam bhante yavagambhiro cayam bhante paticcasamuppado gambhiravabhaso ca atha ca pana me uttanakuttanako viya khayatiti . ma hevam ananda avaca ma hevam ananda avaca gambhiro cayam ^2- paticcasamuppado gambhiravabhaso ca . etassa ananda dhammassa ananubodha appativedha evamayam paja tantakulakajata gunaganthikajata ^3- munjapabbajabhuta ^4- apayam duggatim vinipatam samsaram nativattati. {57.1} Atthi idappaccaya jaramarananti iti putthena sata ananda atthitissa vacaniyam . kimpaccaya jaramarananti iti ce vadeyya jatipaccaya jaramarananti iccassa vacaniyam. {57.2} Atthi idappaccaya jatiti iti putthena sata ananda atthitissa vacaniyam . kimpaccaya jatiti iti ce vadeyya bhavapaccaya jatiti iccassa vacaniyam. {57.3} Atthi idappaccaya bhavoti iti putthena sata ananda atthitissa @Footnote: ¹ kammasadhammantipi patho. ² Ma. Yu. ananda. ³ Ma. Yu. kulaganthikajata. @⁴ Si. munjababbajabhuta.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page66.

Vacaniyam . kimpaccaya bhavoti iti ce vadeyya upadanapaccaya bhavoti iccassa vacaniyam. {57.4} Atthi idappaccaya upadananti iti putthena sata ananda atthitissa vacaniyam . kimpaccaya upadananti iti ce vadeyya tanhapaccaya upadananti iccassa vacaniyam. {57.5} Atthi idappaccaya tanhati iti putthena sata ananda atthitissa vacaniyam . kimpaccaya tanhati iti ce vadeyya vedanapaccaya tanhati iccassa vacaniyam. {57.6} Atthi idappaccaya vedanati iti putthena sata ananda atthitissa vacaniyam . kimpaccaya vedanati iti ce vadeyya phassapaccaya vedanati iccassa vacaniyam. {57.7} Atthi idappaccaya phassoti iti putthena sata ananda atthitissa vacaniyam . kimpaccaya phassoti iti ce vadeyya namarupapaccaya phassoti iccassa vacaniyam. {57.8} Atthi idappaccaya namarupanti iti putthena sata ananda atthitissa vacaniyam . kimpaccaya namarupanti iti ce vadeyya vinnanapaccaya namarupanti iccassa vacaniyam. {57.9} Atthi idappaccaya vinnananti iti putthena sata ananda atthitissa vacaniyam . kimpaccaya vinnananti iti ce vadeyya namarupapaccaya vinnananti iccassa vacaniyam. {57.10} Iti kho ananda namarupapaccaya vinnanam vinnanapaccaya namarupam namarupapaccaya phasso phassapaccaya vedana vedanapaccaya tanha tanhapaccaya upadanam upadanapaccaya bhavo bhavapaccaya

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page67.

Jati jatipaccaya jaramaranam sokaparidevadukkhadomanassupayasa sambhavanti. Evametassa kevalassa dukkhakkhandhassa samudayo hoti. [58] Jatipaccaya jaramarananti iti kho panetam vuttam . Tadananda iminapetam pariyayena veditabbam yatha jatipaccaya jaramaranam . jati ca ^1- hi ananda nabhavissa sabbena sabbam sabbatha sabbam kassaci kimhici seyyathidam devanam va devattaya gandhabbanam va gandhabbattaya yakkhanam va yakkhattaya bhutanam va bhutattaya manussanam va manussattaya catuppadanam va catuppadattaya pakkhinam va pakkhittaya sirimsapanam va sirimsapattaya . Tesam tesanca ^2- hi ananda sattanam tathattaya jati nabhavissa . Sabbaso jatiya asati jatinirodha api nu kho jaramaranam pannayethati . no hetam bhante . Tasmatihananda eseva hetu etam nidanam esa samudayo esa paccayo jaramaranassa yadidam jati. {58.1} Bhavapaccaya jatiti iti kho panetam vuttam . Tadananda iminapetam pariyayena veditabbam yatha bhavapaccaya jati . Bhavo ca ^3- hi ananda nabhavissa sabbena sabbam sabbatha sabbam kassaci kimhici seyyathidam kamabhavo va rupabhavo va arupabhavo va . sabbaso bhave asati bhavanirodha api nu kho jati pannayethati . no hetam bhante . tasmatihananda eseva @Footnote:1-2-3 Yu. va. ito param idisameva.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page68.

Hetu etam nidanam esa samudayo esa paccayo jatiya yadidam bhavo. {58.2} Upadanapaccaya bhavoti iti kho panetam vuttam . Tadananda iminapetam pariyayena veditabbam yatha upadanapaccaya bhavo . upadananca hi ananda nabhavissa sabbena sabbam sabbatha sabbam kassaci kimhici seyyathidam kamupadanam va ditthupadanam va silabbatupadanam va attavadupadanam va . sabbaso upadane asati upadananirodha api nu kho bhavo pannayethati . no hetam bhante . tasmatihananda eseva hetu etam nidanam esa samudayo esa paccayo bhavassa yadidam upadanam. {58.3} Tanhapaccaya upadananti iti kho panetam vuttam . Tadananda iminapetam pariyayena veditabbam yatha tanhapaccaya upadanam . tanha ca hi ananda nabhavissa sabbena sabbam sabbatha sabbam kassaci kimhici seyyathidam rupatanha saddatanha gandhatanha rasatanha photthabbatanha dhammatanha . sabbaso tanhaya asati tanhanirodha api nu kho upadanam pannayethati. No hetam bhante. Tasmatihananda eseva hetu etam nidanam esa samudayo esa paccayo upadanassa yadidam tanha. {58.4} Vedanapaccaya tanhati iti kho panetam vuttam. Tadananda iminapetam pariyayena veditabbam yatha vedanapaccaya tanha . Vedana ca hi ananda nabhavissa sabbena sabbam sabbatha sabbam

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page69.

Kassaci kimhici seyyathidam cakkhusamphassaja vedana sotasamphassaja vedana ghanasamphassaja vedana jivhasamphassaja vedana kayasamphassaja vedana manosamphassaja vedana . sabbaso vedanaya asati vedananirodha api nu kho tanha pannayethati . no hetam bhante . tasmatihananda eseva hetu etam nidanam esa samudayo esa paccayo tanhaya yadidam vedana. [59] Iti kho panetam ananda vedanam paticca tanha tanham paticca pariyesana pariyesanam paticca labho labham paticca vinicchayo vinicchayam paticca chandarago chandaragam paticca ajjhosanam ajjhosanam paticca pariggaho pariggaham paticca macchariyam macchariyam paticca arakkho arakkham ^1- paticca arakkhadhikaranam dandadanasatthadana- kalahaviggahavivadatuvamtuvampesunnamusavada aneke papaka akusala dhamma sambhavantiti iti ^2- kho panetam vuttam . tadananda iminapetam pariyayena veditabbam yatha arakkhadhikaranam dandadanasatthadana- kalahaviggahavivadatuvamtuvampesunnamusavada aneke papaka akusala dhamma sambhavanti ^3-. {59.1} Arakkho ca hi ananda nabhavissa sabbena sabbam sabbatha sabbam kassaci kimhici . sabbaso arakkhe asati arakkhanirodha api nu kho dandadanasatthadanakalahaviggahavivadatuvamtuvampesunnamusavada aneke papaka akusala dhamma sambhaveyyunti . no hetam bhante . tasmatihananda eseva hetu etam nidanam @Footnote: ¹ Ma. Yu. arakkham paticcati pathadvayam natthi. ² Ma. Yu. iti kho panetam @vuttam .pe. veditabbam yathati ime patha natthi. ³ Ma. Yu. sambhavantiti @ito kho panetam veditabbam yatha.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page70.

Esa samudayo esa paccayo dandadanasatthadanakalahaviggaha- vivadatuvamtuvampesunnamusavadanam anekesam papakanam akusalanam dhammanam sambhavaya yadidam arakkho. {59.2} Macchariyam paticca arakkhoti iti kho panetam vuttam. Tadananda ^1- iminapetam pariyayena veditabbam yatha macchariyam paticca arakkho . Macchariyanca hi ananda nabhavissa sabbena sabbam sabbatha sabbam kassaci kimhici . sabbaso macchariye asati macchariyanirodha api nu kho arakkho pannayethati . no hetam bhante . Tasmatihananda eseva hetu etam nidanam esa samudayo esa paccayo arakkhassa yadidam macchariyam. {59.3} Pariggaham paticca macchariyanti iti kho panetam vuttam. Tadananda iminapetam pariyayena veditabbam yatha pariggaham paticca macchariyam . Pariggaho ca hi ananda nabhavissa sabbena sabbam sabbatha sabbam kassaci kimhici . sabbaso pariggahe asati pariggahanirodha api nu kho macchariyam pannayethati . no hetam bhante . Tasmatihananda eseva hetu etam nidanam esa samudayo esa paccayo macchariyassa yadidam pariggaho. {59.4} Ajjhosanam paticca pariggahoti iti kho panetam vuttam. Tadananda iminapetam pariyayena veditabbam yatha ajjhosanam paticca pariggaho . ajjhosananca hi ananda nabhavissa sabbena sabbam sabbatha sabbam kassaci kimhici . sabbaso ajjhosane asati ajjhosananirodha api nu kho pariggaho @Footnote: ¹ Po. tasmatihananda.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page71.

Pannayethati . no hetam bhante . tasmatihananda eseva hetu etam nidanam esa samudayo esa paccayo pariggahassa yadidam ajjhosanam. {59.5} Chandaragam paticca ajjhosananti iti kho panetam vuttam . tadananda iminapetam pariyayena veditabbam yatha chandaragam paticca ajjhosanam . chandarago ca hi ananda nabhavissa sabbena sabbam sabbatha sabbam kassaci kimhici . sabbaso chandarage asati chandaraganirodha api nu kho ajjhosanam pannayethati . no hetam bhante . tasmatihananda eseva hetu etam nidanam esa samudayo esa paccayo ajjhosanassa yadidam chandarago. {59.6} Vinicchayam paticca chandaragoti iti kho panetam vuttam. Tadananda iminapetam pariyayena veditabbam yatha vinicchayam paticca chandarago . vinicchayo ca hi ananda nabhavissa sabbena sabbam sabbatha sabbam kassaci kimhici . sabbaso vinicchaye asati vinicchayanirodha api nu kho chandarago pannayethati . no hetam bhante . tasmatihananda eseva hetu etam didanam esa samudayo esa paccayo chandaragassa yadidam vinicchayo. {59.7} Labham paticca vinicchayoti iti kho panetam vuttam . Tadananda iminapetam pariyayena veditabbam yatha labham paticca vinicchayo . labho ca hi ananda nabhavissa sabbena sabbam sabbatha sabbam kassaci kimhici . sabbaso labhe asati labhanirodha api nu kho vinicchayo pannayethati . no

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page72.

Hetam bhante . tasmatihananda eseva hetu etam nidanam esa samudayo esa paccayo vinicchayassa yadidam labho. {59.8} Pariyesanam paticca labhoti iti kho panetam vuttam . Tadananda iminapetam pariyayena veditabbam yatha pariyesanam paticca labho . pariyesana ca hi ananda nabhavissa sabbena sabbam sabbatha sabbam kassaci kimhici . sabbaso pariyesanaya asati pariyesananirodha api nu kho labho pannayethati . no hetam bhante . tasmatihananda eseva hetu etam nidanam esa samudayo esa paccayo labhassa yadidam pariyesana. {59.9} Tanham paticca pariyesanati iti kho panetam vuttam . Tadananda iminapetam pariyayena veditabbam yatha tanham paticca pariyesana . tanha ca hi ananda nabhavissa sabbena sabbam sabbatha sabbam kassaci kimhici seyyathidam kamatanha bhavatanha vibhavatanha . sabbaso tanhaya asati tanhanirodha api nu kho pariyesana pannayethati . no hetam bhante . tasmatihananda eseva hetu etam nidanam esa samudayo esa paccayo pariyesanaya yadidam tanha. [60] Iti kho ananda ime dve dhamma dvayena vedanaya ekasamosarana bhavanti. {60.1} Phassapaccaya vedanati iti kho panetam vuttam . Tadananda iminapetam pariyayena veditabbam yatha phassapaccaya vedana ^1- . phasso ca hi ananda nabhavissa sabbena @Footnote: ¹ Ma. vedanati.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page73.

Sabbam sabbatha sabbam kassaci kimhici seyyathidam cakkhusamphasso sotasamphasso ghanasamphasso jivhasamphasso kayasamphasso manosamphasso . sabbaso phasse asati phassanirodha api nu kho vedana pannayethati . no hetam bhante . tasmatihananda eseva hetu etam nidanam esa samudayo esa paccayo vedanaya yadidam phasso. {60.2} Namarupapaccaya phassoti iti kho panetam vuttam. Tadananda iminapetam pariyayena veditabbam yatha namarupapaccaya phasso . Yehi ananda akarehi yehi lingehi yehi nimittehi yehi uddesehi namakayassa pannatti hoti tesu akaresu tesu lingesu tesu nimittesu tesu uddesesu asati api nu kho rupakaye adhivacanasamphasso pannayethati . no hetam bhante . yehi ananda akarehi yehi lingehi yehi nimittehi yehi uddesehi rupakayassa pannatti hoti tesu akaresu tesu lingesu tesu nimittesu tesu uddesesu asati api nu kho namakaye patighasamphasso pannayethati . no hetam bhante . yehi ananda akarehi yehi lingehi yehi nimittehi yehi uddesehi namakayassa ca rupakayassa ca pannatti hoti tesu akaresu tesu lingesu tesu nimittesu tesu uddesesu asati api nu kho adhivacanasamphasso va patighasamphasso va pannayethati . No hetam bhante . yehi ananda akarehi yehi lingehi yehi nimittehi yehi uddesehi namarupassa pannatti hoti tesu

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page74.

Akaresu tesu lingesu tesu nimittesu tesu uddesesu asati api nu kho phasso pannayethati . no hetam bhante . Tasmatihananda eseva hetu etam nidanam esa samudayo esa paccayo phassassa yadidam namarupam. {60.3} Vinnanapaccaya namarupanti iti kho panetam vuttam . Tadananda iminapetam pariyayena veditabbam yatha vinnanapaccaya namarupam . vinnananca hi ananda matu kucchismim na okkamissatha api nu kho namarupam matu kucchismim samucchijjissathati. No hetam bhante. Vinnananca hi ananda matu kucchismim okkamitva vokkamissatha api nu kho namarupam itthattaya abhinibbattissathati . no hetam bhante . vinnananca hi ananda daharasseva sato vocchijjissatha kumarakassa va kumarikaya va api nu kho namarupam vuddhim virulhim vepullam apajjissathati . no hetam bhante . tasmatihananda eseva hetu etam nidanam esa samudayo esa paccayo namarupassa yadidam vinnanam. {60.4} Namarupapaccaya vinnananti iti kho panetam vuttam . Tadananda iminapetam pariyayena veditabbam yatha namarupapaccaya vinnanam . vinnananca hi ananda namarupe patittham na labhimssatha api nu kho ayatim jatijaramaranadukkhasamudayasambhavo pannayethati . No hetam bhante . tasmatihananda eseva hetu etam nidanam esa samudayo esa paccayo vinnanassa yadidam namarupam . ettavata kho @Footnote: ¹ Yu. matukucchim. ito param idisameva.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page75.

Ananda jayetha va jiyetha va miyetha va cavetha va upapajjetha va. Ettavata kho adhivacanapatho ettavata niruttipatho ettavata pannattipatho ettavata pannavacaram ettavata vattam vattati . Itthattam pannapanaya yadidam namarupam saha vinnanena. ^[1]- [61] Kittavata ca ananda attanam pannapento pannapeti ^2-. Rupim va hi ananda parittam attanam pannapento pannapeti rupi me paritto attati . rupim va hi ananda anantam attanam pannapento pannapeti rupi me ananto attati . arupim va hi ananda parittam attanam pannapento pannapeti arupi me paritto attati . arupim va hi ananda anantam attanam pannapento pannapeti arupi me ananto attati. {61.1} Tatrananda yo so rupim parittam attanam pannapento pannapeti etarahi va so rupim parittam attanam pannapento pannapeti tathabhavim ^3- va so rupim parittam attanam pannapento pannapeti atatham va pana santam tathattaya upakappessamiti iti va panassa hoti. Evam santam kho ananda rupim parittattanuditthi anusetiti iccalam vacanaya. {61.2} Tatrananda yo so rupim anantam attanam pannapento pannapeti etarahi va so rupim anantam attanam pannapento pannapeti tathabhavim ^4- va so rupim anantam attanam pannapento pannapeti @Footnote: ¹ Si. Ma. annamannapaccayata pavattati. ² pannapento pannapetitipi patho. @3-4 Ma. Yu. tattha bhavim. ito param idisameva.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page76.

Atatham va pana santam tathattaya upakappessamiti iti va panassa hoti . evam santam kho ananda rupim anantattanuditthi anusetiti iccalam vacanaya. {61.3} Tatrananda yo so arupim parittam attanam pannapento pannapeti etarahi va so arupim parittam attanam pannapento pannapeti tathabhavim va so arupim parittam attanam pannapento pannapeti atatham va pana santam tathattaya upakappessamiti iti va panassa hoti . evam santam kho ananda arupim parittattanuditthi anusetiti iccalam vacanaya. {61.4} Tatrananda yo so arupim anantam attanam pannapento pannapeti etarahi va so arupim anantam attanam pannapento pannapeti tathabhavim va so arupim anantam attanam pannapento pannapeti atatham va pana santam tathattaya upakappessamiti iti va panassa hoti. Evam santam kho ananda arupim anantattanuditthi anusetiti iccalam vacanaya. Ettavata kho ananda attanam pannapento pannapetiti. [62] Kittavata ca ananda attanam na pannapento na pannapeti . rupim va hi ananda parittam attanam na pannapento na pannapeti rupi me paritto attati . rupim va hi ananda anantam attanam na pannapento na pannapeti rupi me ananto attati . arupim va hi ananda parittam attanam na pannapento na pannapeti arupi me paritto attati . arupim va hi ananda @Footnote: ¹ Ma. Yu. pannapeti.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page77.

Anantam attanam na pannapento na pannapeti arupi me ananto attati. {62.1} Tatrananda yo so rupim parittam attanam na pannapento na pannapeti etarahi va so rupim parittam attanam na pannapento na pannapeti tathabhavim va so rupim parittam attanam na pannapento na pannapeti atatham va pana santam tathattaya upakappessamiti iti va panassa na hoti . evam santam kho ananda rupim parittattanuditthi nanusetiti iccalam vacanaya. {62.2} Tatrananda yo so rupim anantam attanam na pannapento na pannapeti etarahi va so rupim anantam attanam na pannapento na pannapeti tathabhavim va so rupim anantam attanam na pannapento na pannapeti atatham va pana santam tathattaya upakappessamiti iti va panassa na hoti . evam santam kho ananda rupim anantattanuditthi nanusetiti iccalam vacanaya. {62.3} Tatrananda yo so arupim parittam attanam na pannapento na pannapeti etarahi va so arupim parittam attanam na pannapento na pannapeti tathabhavim va so arupim parittam attanam na pannapento na pannapeti atatham va pana santam tathattaya upakappessamiti iti va panassa na hoti . evam santam kho ananda arupim parittattanuditthi nanusetiti iccalam vacanaya. {62.4} Tatrananda yo so arupim anantam attanam na pannapento na pannapeti etarahi va so arupim anantam attanam na pannapento

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page78.

Na pannapeti tathabhavim va so arupim anantam attanam na pannapento na pannapeti atatham va pana santam tathattaya upakappessamiti iti va panassa na hoti . evam santam kho ananda arupim anantattanuditthi nanusetiti iccalam vacanaya . ettavata kho ananda attanam na pannapento na pannapetiti. [63] Kittavata ca ananda attanam samanupassamano samanupassati . vedanam va hi ananda attanam samanupassamano samanupassati vedana me attati na heva kho me vedana atta appatisamvedano me attati ^[1]- . na heva kho me vedana atta nopi appatisamvedano me atta atta me vedayati vedanadhammo hi me attati iti va hi ananda attanam samanupassamano samanupassati. {63.1} Tatrananda yo so evamaha vedana me attati so evamassa vacaniyo tisso kho ima avuso vedana sukha vedana dukkha vedana adukkhamasukha vedana imasam kho tvam tissannam vedananam katamam attato samanupassasiti . yasmim ananda samaye sukham vedanam vedeti neva tasmim samaye dukkham vedanam vedeti na adukkhamasukham vedanam vedeti sukhamyeva tasmim samaye vedanam vedeti. Yasmim ananda samaye dukkham vedanam vedeti neva tasmim samaye sukham vedanam vedeti na adukkhamasukham vedanam vedeti dukkhamyeva tasmim samaye vedanam vedeti . yasmim ananda samaye adukkhamasukham @Footnote: ¹ Ma. Yu. iti va hi ananda samanupassamano samanupassati.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page79.

Vedanam vedeti neva tasmim samaye sukham vedanam vedeti na dukkham vedanam vedeti adukkhamasukhamyeva tasmim samaye vedanam vedeti. {63.2} Sukhapi kho ananda vedana anicca sankhata paticcasamuppanna khayadhamma vayadhamma viragadhamma nirodhadhamma . Dukkhapi kho ananda vedana anicca sankhata paticcasamuppanna khayadhamma vayadhamma viragadhamma nirodhadhamma . adukkhamasukhapi kho ananda vedana anicca sankhata paticcasamuppanna khayadhamma vayadhamma viragadhamma nirodhadhamma . tassa sukham vedanam vedayamanassa eso me attati hoti tassayeva sukhaya vedanaya nirodha byaga me attati hoti . dukkham vedanam vedayamanassa eso me attati hoti . tassayeva dukkhaya vedanaya nirodha byaga me attati hoti . adukkhamasukham vedanam vedayamanassa eso me attati hoti tassayeva adukkhamasukhaya vedanaya nirodha byaga me attati hoti. Iti so ditthe va dhamme aniccam sukhadukkhavokinnam uppadavayadhammam attanam samanupassamano samanupassati yo so evamaha vedana me attati . tasmatihananda etenapetam nakkhamati vedana me attati samanupassitum {63.3} tatrananda yo so evamaha na heva kho me vedana atta appatisamvedano me attati so evamassa vacaniyo yattha panavuso sabbaso vedayitam atthi ^1- api nu kho tattha asmiti ^2- @Footnote: ¹ Ma. Yu. natthi. ² Ma. ayamahamasmiti. ito param idisameva.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page80.

Siyati . no hetam bhante . tasmatihananda etenapetam nakkhamati na heva kho me vedana atta appatisamvedano me attati samanupassitum. {63.4} Tatrananda yo so evamaha na heva kho me vedana atta nopi appatisamvedano ^[1]- atta atta me vedayati vedanadhammo hi me attati . so evamassa vacaniyo vedana ca hi avuso sabbena sabbam sabbatha sabbam aparisesa nirujjheyyum sabbaso vedanaya asati vedananirodha api nu kho tattha ahamasmiti ^2- siyati. No hetam bhante. Tasmatihananda etenapetam nakkhamati na heva kho me vedana atta nopi appatisamvedano ^[3]- atta atta me vedayati vedanadhammo hi me attati samanupassitum. [64] Yato kho ananda bhikkhu neva vedanam attanam samanupassati nopi appatisamvedanam attanam samanupassati nopi atta ^[4]- vedayati vedanadhammo hi me attati samanupassati . So evam samanupassanto ^5- na ^6- kinci loke upadiyati anupadiyanca na paritassati aparitassam paccattanneva parinibbayati khina jati vusitam brahmacariyam katam karaniyam naparam itthattayati pajanati . evam vimuttam ^7- kho ananda bhikkhum yo evam vadeyya hoti tathagato parammarana itisa ditthiti ^8- tadakallam . na hoti tathagato parammarana @Footnote:1-3-4 Ma. Yu. me. ² Yu. ayamahamasmiti. ⁵ Ma. nasamanupassanto. @Yu. asamanupassanto. ⁶ Ma. na ca. ⁷ Ma. Yu. vimuttacittam. @⁸ itissa ditthititipi patho.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page81.

Itisa ditthiti tadakallam . hoti ca na ca hoti tathagato parammarana itisa ditthiti tadakallam . neva hoti na na hoti tathagato parammarana itisa ditthiti tadakallam . tam kissa hetu . Yavatananda adhivacanam yavata adhivacanapatho yavata niruttipatho ^1- yavata pannatti yavata pannattipatho yavata pannapanam yavata pannavacaram yavata vattam vattati tavata vattam vattati tadabhinna vimutto bhikkhu tadabhinna vimuttam bhikkhum na janati na passati itisa ditthiti tadakallam. [65] Satta kho ima ^2- ananda vinnanatthitiyo dve ayatanani . katama satta . santananda satta nanattakaya nanattasannino seyyathapi manussa ekacce ca deva ekacce ca vinipatika ayam pathama vinnanatthiti . santananda satta nanattakaya ekattasannino seyyathapi deva brahmakayika pathamabhinibbatta catuapayika ^3- satta ca ayam dutiya vinnanatthiti. Santananda satta ekattakaya nanattasannino seyyathapi deva abhassara ayam tatiya vinnanatthiti . santananda satta ekattakaya ekattasannino seyyathapi deva subhakinha ayam catuttha vinnanatthiti . santananda satta sabbaso rupasannanam samatikkama patighasannanam atthangama nanattasannanam amanasikara ananto akasoti akasanancayatanupaga ayam pancama @Footnote: ¹ Ma. Yu. nirutti. ² Ma. ayam patho natthi. ³ Ma. Yu. @catuapayika sattati ime dve patha natthi.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page82.

Vinnanatthiti . santananda satta sabbaso akasanancayatanam samatikkamma anantam vinnananti vinnanancayatanupaga ayam chattha vinnanatthiti . santananda satta sabbaso vinnanancayatanam samatikkamma natthi kinciti akincannayatanupaga ayam sattama vinnanatthiti . asannisattayatanam ^1- nevasannanasannayatanameva dutiyam. {65.1} Tatrananda yayam pathama vinnanatthiti nanattakaya nanattasannino seyyathapi manussa ekacce ca deva ekacce ca vinipatika yo nu kho ananda tanca pajanati tassa ca samudayam pajanati tassa ca atthangamam pajanati tassa ca assadam pajanati tassa ca adinavam pajanati tassa ca nissaranam pajanati kallam nu tena tadabhinanditunti . no hetam bhante .pe. tatrananda yayam sattama vinnanatthiti sabbaso vinnanancayatanam samatikkamma natthi kinciti akincannayatanupaga yo nu kho ananda tanca pajanati tassa ca samudayam pajanati tassa ca atthangamam pajanati tassa ca assadam pajanati tassa ca adinavam pajanati tassa ca nissaranam pajanati kallam nu tena tadabhinanditunti . no hetam bhante . Tatrananda yamidam asannisattayatanam yo nu kho ananda tanca pajanati tassa ca samudayam pajanati tassa ca atthangamam @Footnote: ¹ asannasattayatananti va patho.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page83.

Pajanati tassa ca assadam pajanati tassa ca adinavam pajanati tassa ca nissaranam pajanati kallam nu tena tadabhinanditunti. No hetam bhante . tatrananda yamidam nevasannanasannayatanam yo nu kho ananda tanca pajanati tassa ca samudayam pajanati tassa ca atthangamam pajanati tassa ca assadam pajanati tassa ca adinavam pajanati tassa ca nissaranam pajanati kallam nu tena tadabhinanditunti . no hetam bhante . yato kho ananda bhikkhu imasanca sattannam vinnanatthitinam imesanca dvinnam ayatananam samudayanca atthangamanca assadanca adinavanca nissarananca yathabhutam viditva anupada vimutto hoti ayam vuccatananda bhikkhu pannavimutto. [66] Attha kho ime ananda vimokkha . katame attha . Rupi rupani passati ayam pathamo vimokkho . ajjhattamarupasanni bahiddharupani passati ayam dutiyo vimokkho . subhanteva adhimutto hoti ayam tatiyo vimokkho . sabbaso rupasannanam samatikkamma patighasannanam atthangama nanattasannanam amanasikara ananto akasoti akasanancayatanam upasampajja viharati ayam catuttho vimokkho . sabbaso akasanancayatanam samatikkamma anantam vinnananti vinnanancayatanam upasampajja viharati ayam pancamo vimokkho . sabbaso vinnanancayatanam samatikkamma

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page84.

Natthi kinciti akincannayatanam upasampajja viharati ayam chattho vimokkho . sabbaso akincannayatanam samatikkamma nevasannanasannayatanam upasampajja viharati ayam sattamo vimokkho . sabbaso nevasannanasannayatanam samatikkamma sannavedayitam nirodham upasampajja viharati ayam atthamo vimokkho . Ime kho ananda attha vimokkha. {66.1} Yato kho ananda bhikkhu ime attha vimokkhe anulomampi samapajjati patilomampi samapajjati anulomapatilomampi samapajjati yatthicchakam yadicchakam yavaticchakam samapajjatipi vutthatipi asavananca khaya anasavam cetovimuttim pannavimuttim ditthe va dhamme sayam abhinna sacchikatva upasampajja viharati ayam vuccatananda bhikkhu ubhatobhagavimutto. Imaya ca ananda ubhatobhagavimuttiya anna ubhatobhagavimutti uttaritara va panitatara va natthiti . idamavoca bhagava. Attamano ayasma anando bhagavato bhasitam abhinanditi. Mahanidanasuttam nitthitam dutiyam. ---------------